Here's Edward Tufte on the design of the iPhone interface.
Immensely interesting and well-argued, but I'm not sure I'm with you 100% on this one Ed...
The logic of Tufte here is perhaps quite sound to a point (if a little condescending in tone in its
presentation). But – paraphrasing Graphpaper: do I really need to see a radar image of a city's
weather when I'm quickly checking the temperature whilst walking to a
meeting down a busy street whilst dodging a skateboarder? Don't think so. But Tufte does. He's of the opinion that more information is better on the screens of our mobile devices – and it's an interesting point.
But – using a simple finger-click to jump to another level of a visually appealling, (and very easily understood) device interface to access more information – if you really need it – is no problem for most people. Many (especially 'young people') would wonder what to do with that finger if they're not actively clicking it someplace on their device (it burns calories too). I'm more than happy to click away to the radar image if I really (really?) need to see one. Ditto for any other layer of information that I really don't need to know immediately and/or at a glance whilst 'on the go'. I'm also content to click and explore within levels of the interface/information when time and availability of a comfy couch permits. It's fun.
And besides - examine the image above. I know which interface I'd prefer to use: (the existing Apple one on the left). It looks like Friday is going to be hotter than Thursday. Do I need the right interface's icons, numerals, text and radar to tell me that? Nope.
I concur with Graphpaper's solid criticism of Tufte here. "From all of this, I am not getting a strong feeling that
Tufte is up to speed on how we do things on the Internets these days.
If this is Tufte vs. Jobs, this one goes to Jobs hands-down".
Tufte's presentation is a 56MB movie file download (which neatly illustrates Graphpaper's point). It comes across a little like 'the old dog' not biting perhaps, but certainly nipping, 'the new dog'.
Via Information Aesthetics.